SB 5319
SignedSenate
Surface mine reclamation
Establishing surface mine reclamation permit fees.
- Introduced (completed)
- Committee (completed)
- Floor Vote (completed)
- Opposite Chamber (completed)
- Governor (completed)
- Signed (completed)
How does a bill become law?
- Introduced: The bill is filed and assigned a number.
- Committee: A subject-matter committee holds hearings, takes public testimony, and decides whether to advance the bill.
- Floor Vote: The full chamber (House or Senate) debates and votes on the bill.
- Opposite Chamber: The bill repeats the committee and floor vote process in the other chamber.
- Governor: The Governor reviews the bill and decides whether to sign or veto it.
- Signed: The bill has been signed into law.
AI Analysis
This bill increases fees for surface mine reclamation permits and revisions, including a new $4,500 application fee for all permit types and an annual fee of $3,500 (up from $2,000). It also clarifies fee structures for public works mines and strengthens enforcement tools for collecting unpaid fees.
- Raises the application fee for new, expanded, revised, or combined reclamation permits to $4,500 (was $4,500 for some, but now standardized for all types).
- Raises the annual permit fee for most operators to $3,500 (was $2,000).
- Sets the annual fee for public works mines at $2,500 (was lower or waived for small counties).
- Requires the Department of Natural Resources to notify applicants within 60 days if their application is missing needed information.
- Allows the department to refer delinquent fees or fines to a collection agency, which may add its own collection fees.
- Requires all collected fees to go into the surface mining reclamation account, used for land restoration after mining.
Who is affected
- Surface mine operators (private and public) — Must pay higher application fees ($4,500) for new, expanded, or revised reclamation permits, and annual fees ($3,500) to maintain permits.
- Counties operating public works mines — May pay a reduced annual fee of $2,500 if the mine is used exclusively for public works projects and meets specific legal definitions.
- State Department of Natural Resources — Will receive increased application and annual fees, and may receive funding allocations for enforcement if they take on mining oversight responsibilities.
- Mine operators with delinquent payments — May be contacted by collection agencies if fees or fines go unpaid, and could face permit suspension or fines.
Pro/Con Analysis
Potential Benefits (5)
Higher fees fund the Surface Mining Reclamation Account, supporting state-led land restoration and reducing long-term environmental degradation from abandoned or under-reclaimed sites — benefiting public health and ecosystem services.
EnvironmentPeopleRef: Sec. 1(3)(a), (4)Standardized application review timeline improves regulatory predictability and reduces permit delays, which can prevent unsafe or informal mining practices during waiting periods.
Public SafetyPeopleRef: Sec. 1(8)Enhanced enforcement tools (e.g., collection agency referrals) help ensure operators fulfill financial obligations for reclamation, reducing risk of taxpayer-funded cleanup of abandoned sites.
Public SafetyLean peopleRef: Sec. 1(9)Increased fee revenue supports DNR’s capacity to monitor and enforce reclamation standards across the state, strengthening oversight of mining impacts on local water, air, and soil quality.
Local GovernmentPeopleRef: Sec. 1(3)(a), (4)Public works mine fee clarification ($2,500) provides regulatory certainty for counties, potentially improving planning for infrastructure projects and reducing legal ambiguity around fee waivers.
Business & EmploymentPeopleRef: Sec. 1(3)(b)
Potential Concerns (5)
Increases operating costs for surface mine operators through standardized $4,500 application fees and $3,500 annual fees (up from $2,000), which may reduce profitability or delay new/expanded operations — especially for small-scale or marginally viable operations.
Business & EmploymentRef: Sec. 1(1)(d), (2), (3)(a)Public works mines (e.g., county road aggregate operations) now pay $2,500 annual fee (up from $1,000 or waived), potentially straining county budgets for essential infrastructure projects like road building and maintenance.
Local GovernmentRef: Sec. 1(3)(b)Mandates 60-day response timeline for DNR on incomplete applications, which may increase administrative burden on small operators who lack legal or technical staff to navigate bureaucratic delays.
Local GovernmentRef: Sec. 1(8)Authorizes referral of delinquent fees/fines to collection agencies, potentially adding financial stress and legal exposure for small operators who experience cash-flow disruptions.
Business & EmploymentRef: Sec. 1(9)Fee increases may reduce incentive to invest in reclamation compliance, especially for marginal operations, potentially increasing long-term environmental liability if operators exit without full remediation.
Business & EmploymentRef: Sec. 1(3)(a)
Who Is Most Affected
- Private surface mine operatorsNegative Impact
Private surface mine operators — especially small-scale or marginal operations — face higher upfront and recurring costs, which may reduce profitability or delay operations.
- Counties operating public works minesNegative Impact
Counties operating public works mines (e.g., road aggregate operations) now pay higher fees than before, potentially diverting funds from infrastructure priorities.
- State Department of Natural ResourcesPositive Impact
State Department of Natural Resources gains increased revenue and enforcement tools, improving its capacity to fund and enforce reclamation obligations.
- General publicPositive Impact
General public benefits from improved environmental outcomes (cleaner land/water) and reduced risk of taxpayer-funded cleanup of abandoned mine sites.
- Washington taxpayersMixed Impact
Taxpayers benefit indirectly from reduced long-term liability for environmental cleanup, though they may bear some cost if fee revenue is insufficient to cover reclamation needs.
Sponsors
- Senator Shewmake(Democrat)District 42Primary
- Senator Chapman(Democrat)District 24Secondary
- Senator Nobles(Democrat)District 28Secondary